Robust hot pepper cheese, luscious tomatoes, rich fresh garlic & juicy hot peppers.
Classic pie loaded with tangy pepperoni, savory mushrooms & crisp green peppers.
Fresh made peasant dough (no preservatives) hand tossed & stretched into the traditional thin crust pie. Generous portion of our rich, homemade sauce seasoned to perfection resulting in that rich tantalizing taste. Smothered in the finest whole milk provolone cheese with your favorite fresh toppings, then oven baked in our seasoned pans … your own savory masterpiece is complete.
Pizzi Cafe, founded in 1934 by Anthony (Tony) and Mary Pizzi, started as an Italian neighborhood bar where friends could meet and enjoy drinks and conversations.
Following a trip to visit family in Boston, Tony Pizzi came across and acquired the original pizza recipe for Pizzi Cafe. At that time pizza was an Italian family food that was only made in the home in square sheets. So Tony Pizzi brought back to Northeast Ohio this recipe for round pizza, which no one had ever seen before….and the rest is history.
The lasagna was STUPENDOUS! Nice dining atmosphere !
Our first time here - but not our last !! Great pizza - food had Old Family taste.
Great Service. The best we have had in a long time.
How do you improve perfect?!
I’ve enjoyed Pizzi Café since I was very young. It is my very favorite place when looking for great food, friendly conversation and seeing friends. I will always have Pizzi Café as #1 on my list of places to go!
Pizzi Café is a jewel of an Italian Restaurant. It is worth the trip from ANYWHERE
Always a positive experience!
Your Pizza Rocks! NOTHING like it in Erie.
Great Food!! Great Service !! Great Atmosphere ! Our waitress was THE BEST! Pizzi Café is a Hidden Treasure!”
Discovered Pizzi Café last year – A Gem – Everything
Food is GREAT! Very Unique, Neat & Clean. We will continue to drive from Hermitage, PA and bring our friends to enjoy Pizzi Café and the very friendly service.
Very cozy and friendly atmosphere with GREAT food! We are excited to have discovered Pizzi Café.
I have never been a pizza person until I tried yours. Service is always great!.
An old recipe we discovered that Grandma Pizzi made just for her family and close friends. Our peasant dough lightly covered with olive oil, then a layer of fresh Mozzarella and Provolone cheeses. Topped with mildly spiced fresh tomato chunks then sprinkled with Romano cheese.